Saturday, October 24, 2009

Hindrances to Making Good Music - Robert Cottrill

If we are to evaluate music on the basis of its origins, we must not only consider the general origin–that God gave us the gift of music. We also need to consider the human element, the origin of each piece of music. Though we have no way of making a comparison, it seems logical to suppose that, were it not for the fall, man would have been able to produce even more glorious and consistently God-honouring songs. But sin has changed all that. Now, we face an ongoing struggle against the world, the flesh and the devil. That is what hinders us from making good music to the glory of God.

1) The Pressure of the World
This evil world, Satan’s kingdom, with its triple anti-God dogmas of egocentrism, materialism, and sensuality, has aggressively incorporated music as another means to achieve its temporal goals, and communicate its sinful philosophy. And the influence of the world exerts pressure on the one who desires to serve Christ (Rom. 12:2). If we are not on guard, it will affect the music we create and use.

2) The Perversity of the Flesh
Apart from the regenerating work of the Spirit of God, men are spiritually dead (Eph. 2:1, 5). Even after the new birth has taken place, our powers are sadly diminished in comparison to what they might have been–and will one day be again. The flesh (the sin nature) is in continual rebellion against the spirit, within the child of God. (Gal. 5:17). This too will tend to affect our music.

3) The Persuasion of the Devil
Further, we have Satan to contend with. He is intent on using everything God has made for a dishonest and destructive purpose (Jn. 8:44; Eph. 6:12). That objective has historically included his appropriation and employment of God’s gift of music (cf. Exod. 32:4-6, 17-19; Job 30:9; Lam. 3:63; Dan. 3:5; Amos 6:3-7).

Bottom line: We must be constantly attentive to the spiritual quality of our music, and depend upon the grace of God to render what is pleasing to Him. As a hymn by George Heath puts it:

My soul, be on thy guard;
Ten thousand foes arise;
The hosts of sin are pressing hard
To draw thee from the skies.

O watch, and fight, and pray;
The battle ne’er give o’er;
Renew it boldly every day,
And help divine implore.

Ne’er think the victory won,
Nor lay thine armour down;
The work of faith will not be done,
Till thou obtain the crown.

Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Teenagers and Church Music: What Do They Really Think?

What do teens think is the appropriate kind of music for a worship setting?

An interview with a professor of music education who researched this question provides some interesting answers.


In 1995 Dr. Barbara Resch conducted a survey of nearly 500 teenagers from across the United States on the topic of the appropriateness of music for the church. The research and findings, which are summarized in this interview, formed the basis of Dr. Resch's doctoral dissertation at Indiana University.1


The findings of this research certainly do not answer all of the questions related to the issue of church music. They do, however, provide valuable insights into how the young people in our churches think about these matters. These findings may also challenge us to rethink some of our assumptions about what our youth are looking for in worship.


Dr. Resch is currently professor of music education at Indiana-Purdue University, Fort Wayne, Indiana. She is also director of the children's choir at St. Paul Lutheran Church, Fort Wayne, and has directed the choir in two recordings of hymns and liturgies.


The interview was first published in the Winter 1999 issue of Commission on Worship (vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 3-4), a publication of the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod Commission on Worship. The last three questions were added by the staff of Lutheran Partners magazine.



What motivated you to do this project?

Pastors, youth directors, parents, teachers, church musicians, and anyone who works with and cares about teenagers have probably asked at some point: "How can we keep these kids interested and involved in the church? Now that they're confirmed and off to high school, what can we do to keep them worshiping faithfully?"


Often this discussion has led to an examination of the divine service and further questions: "Is it the music? Wouldn't they rather hear and sing their own music in church? Won't they be much more inclined to hear God's Word if it's accompanied by a musical style that they like?"


What was involved in your research?

Teenagers from Massachusetts to California (numbering 479) were asked for their input on this topic. The students were asked to imagine themselves in a worship service and to determine if each of the 40 musical excerpts they were hearing sounded "appropriate for church," as they knew it.


Since 34 different religious bodies were represented, including Roman Catholic, Baptist, Lutheran, mainline Protestant, non-denominational and Pentecostal churches, world religions, and cultic groups, the students' experiences with church services were diverse.


As you prepared your survey, what results did you expect?

First, I expected that the music deemed appropriate would, like their church affiliations, be diverse. Second, knowing that the vast majority of teenagers enjoy listening to rock and pop music, I also expected that those styles would be identified as appropriate for church by their standards.


What did you learn?

Surprisingly, neither of my predictions proved true. Across this diverse group of students there was clear agreement about the kind of music that was "right for church": it was

* choral music, not instrumental

* sung by a group of singers rather than a soloist

* characterized by a simple musical texture and understandable text.


Musical examples reminiscent of popular styles (rock, jazz, country) were overwhelmingly rejected as church music. The example rated most appropriate was a male choir singing a four-part version of Psalm 98 (The Lutheran Hymnal 667!). The piece considered least appropriate was the loud and rhythmic "Midnight Oil," performed by the Christian rock group Petra.


Were there any common factors that influenced the responses?

Church background was an important predictor of the kind of music considered appropriate. The frequency with which a given style was heard also tended to be related.


For example, some settings of traditional choral music were considered appropriate by nearly everyone. Conversely, the examples of Christian rock and jazz were considered inappropriate by the great majority.


But it was also clear that students from nondenominational churches who heard contemporary Christian music in their churches considered that music more appropriate. Likewise, gospel choir music and popular styles were considered more fitting by students who attended Pentecostal churches.


The traditional choral sound was given its highest ratings by the Catholic and Lutheran students in the study.


What does that information tell you?

What it says is that the kind of music that is heard in a church service seems to become the accepted norm for that context. Contrary to expectations, these representative teenagers do not bring to the church service their own musical preferences (e.g., rock and pop music) as the right music for that occasion.


Rather, they tend to accept as appropriate for that context the music that the church has already put in place, whatever that music may be. While they liked rock music and thought it was the right music for some times and places in their lives, they didn't believe that the church service was that time and place.


Several students wrote comments on their survey sheets indicating when and where each excerpt would be appropriate. Although all of the examples played were representative of the range of music heard in American churches today, the contexts with which the students associated various pieces were Sunday brunch, a movie soundtrack, "church services of the 40s," a campground, and an opera.


They apparently had clear opinions regarding the fittingness of musical styles for particular occasions, including that of the church service.


Not all of the students who took the survey were churchgoers. How did they respond?

Nearly 12 percent of the respondents did not belong to or attend church. As might be expected, their responses were very diverse. One surprise was that their responses were not significantly different from the church members in their disapproval of rock music for church.


Interestingly, the unchurched students gave their lowest ranking of appropriateness to contemporary Christian music. Several wrote on their survey forms "This sounds like my parents' music!"


Any idea what was behind their responses?

Sociologists suggest that teenagers' judgments may be formed by any one of a number of influential groups in different contexts:


their peer groups

a team or organization they belong to

their families

their churches.


The opinions of the church-going students were clearly influenced by their church settings. Lacking that context in which to form opinions, the unchurched teenagers were apparently influenced by the standards of popular culture, which would judge the sound of most contemporary Christian music to be neither contemporary nor popular.


For adolescents who keep current with popular music trends, much contemporary Christian music has a dated sound with a greater appeal to the "fortysomething" generation. While teenagers who have come to know this music as part of the ethos of their church may consider it appropriate, unchurched adolescents may reject it.


Did your research reveal teenagers' attitudes concerning the role of music in worship?

Yes. The study revealed connections between the teens' ideas of the role music takes in the service and the kind of music considered suitable to fill that role. They had been asked on the survey how they thought music functioned in the church service, and they ranked the stated possibilities in this order, from most to least important:


Church music is an expression of religious belief.

Church music is part of the presentation of God's Word.

Church music is a way for people to use their talents to serve God.

Church music establishes or changes people's moods.

Church music is a performance that entertains.


My analysis showed a strong connection between the students' perceptions of the way music functions in the service and the kind of music they thought was appropriate for the service.


Students who saw music as part of the presentation of God's Word considered traditional choral music most appropriate for the service. Those who thought that music functioned to "establish or change people's moods" indicated that contemporary Christian music, a more mellow and easy-listening style, was appropriate.


The small percentage who said that music in church was an entertaining performance also gave higher ratings to rock music and soloistic pop styles.


And the only segment of the respondents who considered instrumental music appropriate were those who thought that church music functioned as "a way for people to use their talents to serve God."


This concern about music's function really lay at the heart of the study, since the main question "Is this appropriate church music?" addressed the way teenagers heard the music as fitting into a particular context.


As they took the survey, they were reminded frequently that they were indicating not how much they liked the music but rather how fitting they felt it was for a specific time and place. As they visualized themselves in a church setting, it is likely that they had an idea of how music should function in that setting, and that their judgments were based on how well the excerpt fulfilled that function.


It is interesting that a great many of these teenagers took Luther's well-known position that music is the servant of the Word.


Did your research yield any other "surprises"?

The students who participated in the survey lent some amazing insight into their view of the church gathered for worship. Many expressed a respect for the corporate nature of their worshiping congregations.


One said she made her decisions based on how the "little old ladies" in her church would react: "If I thought they would be upset I said it was not appropriate, because people shouldn't get upset by music in church." Another wrote: "This would give my Grandma cardiac arrest, so better not!"


One boy had asked at the outset "Do you mean appropriate for me or for the whole congregation?" Who knows how he might have responded if he were a congregation of one, but he realized that he was not, and that appropriate church music is not an age-specific style.


What final insights from your research would you like to share with worship planners?

One insight is the strong influence that established church music practice has on teenagers' opinions about what that music should be. They were accepting of the music they heard in church and did not bring their own personal preference to that place. In fact, they expressed a possessiveness about "their own" rock and popular music styles, and a desire to keep that music in the realm of recreational listening.


Attempts by adults to present an appealing contemporary popular sound were apparently unsuccessful in winning over unchurched students, who measured that sound against cutting-edge pop music and found it lacking.


Another insight is that the teenagers expressed a surprising sense of the corporate nature of worship, embracing a sensitivity to the intergenerational oneness of the worshiping community.


Finally, it's possible that pastors, youth directors, and musicians may have been making decisions based on some false assumptions about teens and church music. It may be appropriate to learn from these young people and ask the same foundational questions: What is _ worship? What is the role of music within _ worship? What, therefore, is appropriate music for the church service?


Four years have passed since you made the original study. What have you learned since the initial study was done? Any changes?

I have heard from many teachers and youth directors that their own experience with teenagers supports the statistical evidence of the study. Typical of these responses is the youth leader at a conference in a large northwestern city who spoke eloquently about his own youth group of more than 60 churched and unchurched teenagers and their fierce possessiveness about "their own" secular musical styles.


These students were adamant about keeping that musical language in the recreational part of the group's activity, and using far more traditional musical styles during their devotional time.


One thing that has changed is what is current in contemporary music. The example of Christian rock music that I used in 1995 is now considered passé. A church that had adopted this music because of its appeal to teenagers would have had to abandon it by now. This phenomenon really gives support to the point that secular musical styles, as a reflection of secular culture, change very quickly.


It seems entirely appropriate that the church, which is a place of stability and permanence in a rapidly changing society, maintain a core of musical expression.


Do you see any changes in the future regarding teens and church music?

As popular music styles become more extreme, it may become increasingly difficult for other institutions, like the church, to adopt a recognizable version of the style that can function in another cultural context. Church leaders may be comfortable with even fewer examples of "crossover" pop in a worship setting.


Decisions about church music practice are driven by a church's theological grounding. I suspect that the church's approach to teenagers will continue to reflect its stance on worship, evangelism, and other aspects of its mission here on earth.


What would you say to the parents of these kids, i.e., would you want to give any words of advice or caution to what parents may or may not be thinking about your findings? In the same vein, what would you say to church leadership?

The study pointed out the influence of things we do and hear regularly. I would encourage parents to keep worship at the heart of their family's life together--to attend church as a family, to have positive conversations about what happens at that time and place, to savor and enjoy this intergenerational gathering of God's people.


Perhaps more than any other age group, adolescents need stability and substance in their lives, and regular worship habits can foster that stability.


While doing the research, I was amazed by the willingness of teens to accept the model of church music that they were hearing. I can't recall ever hearing the idea that this model should change to one of their own design. While I didn't hear the students saying "I really love this music," their enjoyment of the music did not seem to be the issue with them. Instead, they were accepting of what the musical and pastoral leaders of the church had put in place for their congregation.


This perception places an enormous responsibility on church leaders when they realize that the church music practice they establish becomes the congregation's model for appropriate church music. This responsibility is especially crucial as we welcome previously unchurched teens and adults into our fellowship and begin to integrate them into the culture that is the church.


Our coming into God's presence in worship is different from all of our other encounters during the rest of the week. And one distinctive difference is the use of a musical language that is compatible with the unchanging gifts of Word and sacrament that we receive at this place.


Endnote1.

Barbara J. Resch, Adolescents' Attitudes toward the Appropriateness of Religious Music, (Bloomington, Indiana: Indiana University, 1996)

Dr. Barbara J. Resch is currently professor of music education at Indiana-Purdue University, Fort Wayne, Indiana. She is also director of the children's choir at St. Paul Lutheran Church, Fort Wayne (LC-MS), and has directed the choir in two recordings of hymns and liturgies.

The article is reprinted, by permission, from the author and the Lutheran Church ­Missouri Synod Commission on Worship, St. Louis, Missouri. The article was first published in Commission on Worship (St. Louis, Missouri: LC-MS Commission on Worship, Winter 1999, vol. 4, no. 1), pp. 3-4.

Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Mind Your Music!

I'm not sure when this excellent article was written, but it is still relevant! -Editor

Author: Rev (Dr) Tow Siang Hwa from Calvary-Pandan BP Church, Singapore

Ps 104: 24-35Col 3: 16-17

One of the most effective ways of polluting the mind is through music. Our adversary (that wily and crafty customer) uses it to maximum advantage. Last generation it was through swing and jazz. Now, it is pop and rock. With the media explosion of TV, Hi-fi, tapes and video, the air waves are bombarded round the clock with a torrent of filth and mental garbage, available to anybody anywhere at the touch of a switch.

Believing parents and children, we go to great lengths to safeguard our physical well being with every sort of health protective, inoculations, immunizations. Pause a moment and think: What protective measures have we taken to safeguard our mental and spiritual well being? The famous latin proverb says “Mens sana in corpore sano,” meaning to say, “A sound mind in a sound body.” This is so important for us to understand for an Olympic strong man or athlete can be reduced to a physical wreck by drug abuse in a matter of weeks. Similarly, sex abuse can rapidly destroy a morally healthy young person.

Music today has taken on sinister and subversive overtones. A multi-billion dollar industry is churning out red hot top tunes, charged with immoral, suggestive and seductive messages, souped-up with booming soul-stimulating decibels and big drum beats. The target: millions of unwary, pleasure-seeking young people looking for excitement and kicks, drugs and sex. Exposed to the overwhelming barrage of sensuous sounds, many a young person are hooked, and taken as lambs to the slaughter.

Even more noxious, certain rock tapes have hidden occult messages and Satanic signals which come through when played in reverse – an eerie and spine-chilling experience. The devil is running to and fro seeking victims for his kingdom of bondage and death.
It is high time for Christian young people and parents to take stern action against the wiles of the devil. Let us employ the strictest censorship of all musical programmes and tapes, to exclude doubtful or harmful material. Those in our homes, personal libraries, and private collections should be destroyed by fire, to put an end to Satanic mind-washing. Out with immoral pop and rock!

Let our homes be filled with God-honouring music and songs of the Heavenly Kingdom. A Christian’s music should bring glory to God’s name.

Keynote: Sing with grace in your hearts to the Lord.
Prayer: Lord, teach me the songs of Heaven which honour Thee.

Monday, October 12, 2009

Hezekiah's Revival


Hezekiah became king in Judah when he was twenty-five years old. Hezekiah was a good king, who tried very hard to obey the Lord and to restore his land to the worship of the one true God. And, as had been promised in Deuteronomy 11, following God in humble obedience brought Hezekiah God's blessing.
    "He trusted in the LORD God of Israel; so that after him was none like him among all the kings of Judah, nor any that were before him. For he clave to the LORD, and departed not from following him, but kept his commandments, which the LORD commanded Moses. And the LORD was with him; and he prospered whithersoever he went forth." (2 Kings 18:5-7a)

    "And thus did Hezekiah throughout all Judah, and wrought that which was good and right and truth before the LORD his God. And in every work that he began in the service of the house of God, and in the law, and in the commandments, to seek his God, he did it with all his heart, and prospered." (2 Chronicles 31:20-21)
As Hezekiah worked to reinstate the worship of God in the temple, we find that he placed great importance on restoring the music program. It is interesting to note that it was his concern to obey God that prompted his actions. Hezekiah realized that the command to perform music, both vocal and instrumental, as part of the worship ceremony, was originally given by God Himself.
    "And he set the Levites in the house of the LORD with cymbals, with psalteries, and with harps, according to the commandment of David, and of Gad the king's seer, and Nathan the prophet: for so was the commandment of the LORD by his prophets. And the Levites stood with the instruments of David, and the priests with the trumpets. And Hezekiah commanded to offer the burnt offering upon the altar. And when the burnt offering began, the song of the LORD began also with the trumpets, and with the instruments ordained by David king of Israel. And all the congregation worshipped, and the singers sang, and the trumpeters sounded: and all this continued until the burnt offering was finished. And when they had made an end of offering, the king and all that were present with him bowed themselves, and worshipped. Moreover Hezekiah the king and the princes commanded the Levites to sing praise unto the LORD with the words of David, and of Asaph the seer. And they sang praises with gladness, and they bowed their heads and worshipped." (2 Chronicles 29:25-30)
As Hezekiah led the people of Judah in this great revival, music played an important role in expressing the condition of their hearts. Notice that the singers "sang praises with gladness." A right relationship with God produces joy, as well as humility.

A humble, joyous, walk with God that produces a song of praise and an attitude of worship is certainly a great indication of revival in the heart!

Thursday, October 01, 2009

When Morning Gilds The Skies

When morning gilds the skies my heart awaking cries:
may Jesus Christ be praised!
Alike at work and prayer, to Jesus I repair:
may Jesus Christ be praised!

When you begin the day, O never fail to say,
may Jesus Christ be praised!
And at your work rejoice, to sing with heart and voice,
may Jesus Christ be praised!

Whene'er the sweet church bell peals over hill and dell,
may Jesus Christ be praised!
O hark to what it sings, as joyously it rings,
may Jesus Christ be praised!

My tongue shall never tire of chanting with the choir,
may Jesus Christ be praised!
This song of sacred joy, it never seems to cloy,
may Jesus Christ be praised!

Does sadness fill my mind? A solace here I find,
may Jesus Christ be praised!
Or fades my earthly bliss? My comfort still is this,
may Jesus Christ be praised!

To God, the Word, on high, the host of angels cry,
may Jesus Christ be praised!
Let mortals, too, upraise their voice in hymns of praise,
may Jesus Christ be praised!

Be this at meals your grace, in every time and place;
may Jesus Christ be praised!
Be this, when day is past, of all your thoughts the last
may Jesus Christ be praised!

When mirth for music longs, this is my song of songs:
may Jesus Christ be praised!
When evening shadows fall, this rings my curfew call,
may Jesus Christ be praised!

When sleep her balm denies, my silent spirit sighs,
may Jesus Christ be praised!
When evil thoughts molest, with this I shield my breast,
may Jesus Christ be praised!

The night becomes as day when from the heart we say:
may Jesus Christ be praised!
The powers of darkness fear when this sweet chant they hear:
may Jesus Christ be praised!

No lovelier antiphon in all high heaven is known than,
Jesus Christ be praised!
There to the eternal Word the eternal psalm is heard:
may Jesus Christ be praised!

Let all the earth around ring joyous with the sound:
may Jesus Christ be praised!
In heaven's eternal bliss the loveliest strain is this:
may Jesus Christ be praised!

Sing, suns and stars of space, sing, ye that see his face,
sing, Jesus Christ be praised!
God's whole creation o'er, for aye and evermore shall
Jesus Christ be praised!

In heaven's eternal bliss the loveliest strain is this,
may Jesus Christ be praised!
Let earth, and sea and sky from depth to height reply,
may Jesus Christ be praised!

Be this, while life is mine, my canticle divine:
may Jesus Christ be praised!
Sing this eternal song through all the ages long:
may Jesus Christ be praised!

Tuesday, September 29, 2009

Take My Life, and Let It Be

Take My Life and Let It Be


Take my life, and let it be
Consecrated, Lord, to Thee;
Take my moments and my days,
Let them flow in ceaseless praise.
Let them flow in ceaseless praise.



Take my hands, and let them move
At the impulse of Thy love;
Take my feet, and let them be
Swift and beautiful for Thee.
Swift and beautiful for Thee.




Take my voice, and let me sing
Always, only, for my King;
Take my lips, and let them be
Filled with messages from Thee.
Filled with messages from Thee.



Take my silver and my gold:
Not a mite would I withhold;
Take my intellect, and use
Ev'ry pow'r as Thou shalt choose.
Ev'ry pow'r as Thou shalt choose.




Take my will, and make it Thine,
It shall be no longer mine;
Take my heart, it is Thine own,
It shall be Thy royal throne.
It shall be Thy royal throne.



Take my love, my Lord, I pour
At Thy feet its treasure store;
Take myself, and I will be,
Ever, only, all for Thee.
Ever, only, all for Thee.



1874.




Text: Frances R. Havergal, 1836-1879 Music: Louis J.F. Herold; arr. by George Kingsley

Tuesday, September 22, 2009

Who is on the Lords Side?




Who is on the Lord’s side? Who will serve the King?
Who will be His helpers, other lives to bring?
Who will leave the world’s side? Who will face the foe?
Who is on the Lord’s side? Who for Him will go?
By Thy call of mercy, by Thy grace divine,
We are on the Lord’s side—Savior, we are Thine!

Not for weight of glory, nor for crown and palm,
Enter we the army, raise the warrior psalm;
But for love that claimeth lives for whom He died:
He whom Jesus nameth must be on His side.
By Thy love constraining, by Thy grace divine,
We are on the Lord’s side—Savior, we are Thine!

Jesus, Thou hast bought us, not with gold or gem,
But with Thine own life blood, for Thy diadem;
With Thy blessing filling each who comes to Thee,
Thou hast made us willing, Thou hast made us free.
By Thy grand redemption, by Thy grace divine,
We are on the Lord’s side—Savior, we are Thine!

Fierce may be the conflict, strong may be the foe,
But the King’s own army none can overthrow;
’Round His standard ranging, victory is secure,
For His truth unchanging makes the triumph sure.
Joyfully enlisting, by Thy grace divine,
We are on the Lord’s side—Savior, we are Thine!

Chosen to be soldiers, in an alien land,
Chosen, called, and faithful, for our Captain’s band,
In the service royal, let us not grow cold;
Let us be right loyal, noble, true and bold.
Master, Thou wilt keep us, by Thy grace divine,
Always on the Lord’s side—Savior, always Thine!

Thursday, September 17, 2009

The Importance of Music or The Power of Hymns

A transcript of a discussion on hymns taken from Back To The Bible's program Gateway To Joy. ~Editor

Lisa Barry: Elisabeth, let's start with you. I know that music was an important part of your home life growing up. Can you give us a bird's-eye view of what that was like?

Elisabeth Elliot: We had family prayers every morning and the first thing was to be herded into the living room where either my father or my mother would sit down at the piano and would play usually the next hymn in the book. We went through hymnbooks. It was just taken for granted that all of us would sing. So, whether the children knew how to read the words, it didn't make any difference, because little children can learn the words just by hearing them. So, we would generally sing one hymn, but we didn't skip any of the stanzas as many churches do (we'll sing stanzas 1, 2 and 5 or something). We had all the verses.

Neither of my parents was a virtuoso on the piano, by any means. But they both knew how to play plain, ordinary hymns. I can remember my older brother, Phil, taking piano lessons and about as far as he got was Hop up, hop up, o grasshopper spry (or something like that); and he gave up. I am number two in the family so I had a variety of piano teachers one after another and never really got very far other than just to be able to play hymns. And to this day, I love to sit down to the piano and play hymns by myself. I do it frequently after supper when Lars is upstairs and I've finished the dishes.

Lisa Barry: I think I remember a story of your mother when she was nearing the end of her life and she was having difficulty remembering things. And yet she was always able to play the piano, wasn't she? And you were surprised by that.

Elisabeth Elliot: Yes, she was staying in a retirement home in Pennsylvania and when I visited her, we were just walking through the place and there was a piano there and I said, "Mother, why don't you sit down there and play the piano?"

And she said, "Oh, I can't play the piano."

And I said, "What do you mean you can't? You've always played the piano."

So she said, "All right, I'll try." And she sat down and she didn't have any trouble at all. It was all in her head. She didn't need a book. So, each time I would go there to visit, I would always make sure that she sat down at the piano and played.

Lisa Barry: Elisabeth, what are some of your favorite hymns?

Elisabeth Elliot: I have a long list right here in my book on my favorite quotations, my favorite hymns. And it is a long list. I won't read them all but I can show it to you. Nobody that is listening can see it, but it is in alphabetical order so I started with "All Hail the Power of Jesus' Name," "And Can It Be?" "Beneath the Cross of Jesus," "Be Still My Soul," "Crown Him With Many Crowns"...how far do you want me to go?

Lisa Barry: Hearing that "Be Still My Soul," you've heard the story probably of Eric Liddle who as he was dying of a brain tumor in a Chinese prison camp, he loved hymns as well--had grown up in a family that loved hymns--and apparently, as I understand the story, he sent a nurse out to the front of the hospital where there was a Salvation Army band that had gathered together in that prison camp (a makeshift band) and asked if they would play for him "Be Still, My Soul." And apparently just days, perhaps weeks, before he went to be with the Lord, that was the hymn that they played so he could hear it inside the hospital.

Elisabeth Elliot: I hadn't heard that story.

Lisa Barry: I can remember going through a very difficult time in my life around age 20. I would take my hymnbook, sit in front of the fire, and just read the words. I didn't know a lot of the tunes; I just read the words. And they are so powerful. Hymns can minister to us in so many ways. Can you think of a time when a particular hymn really ministered to you, Nancy?

Nancy Leigh DeMoss: Why, hymns have ministered deeply to me my whole life. I came actually from a family that was musical on one side much more than on the other. My mother was a wonderful musician, had a great gift with the piano, but also as an accomplished singer. None of us inherited her vocal ability.

But my dad, who really had no ear for music at all, but a great love for praising and worshiping the Lord, had it in his mind that somehow we should be a musical family. He would ask us to sing a table grace for guests that we would have in the home. Or even I can remember taking part of our family on a vacation--a ministry vacation to Korea--and my dad making us little girls sing and play for soldiers on a military base there where he was preaching but he wanted us to sing for them. We could be as off-key as possible and he would not know the difference.

I can remember my parents marching us to what seemed like it was always the front row of church and lining us up and we would sing songs, some of my dad's favorites. What can wash away my sin? Nothing but the blood of Jesus. Hear him kind of clapping his hands together, this is not because the audience was clapping, but just because he was so caught up in the wonder of what God had done for him.

So we grew up hearing my mother sing beautifully and then my dad having a great appreciation for it. In fact, my mother many years ago recorded two--they were called "albums" in those days--one an Easter collection and one a Thanksgiving collection with the London Philharmonic Orchestra and Paul Mickelson orchestrating the arrangements. And to this day one of the traditions in my own walk is on Thanksgiving and on Easter, I pull those tapes out (we've transferred them to cassette tape). And as old as they are, and not great--certainly not broadcast--quality today, but I listen to those and am so reminded of those songs and hymns and texts that were so much a part of our learning doctrine and theology and the ways of God as children.

Lisa Barry: Which brings us to the present. Not too many people are singing the hymns the way they used to.

Elisabeth Elliot: Wouldn't it be wonderful if we could get people to recognize the tremendous blessing that there is in the theology of the old hymns! It doesn't bother me that people sing praise songs, but it bothers me if that's all they sing. The praise songs generally have a lot of repetition and very thin theology. Whereas as I look at this list that I have, I wonder how many people in today's churches would know "God Moves In A Mysterious Way," "Great Is Thy Faithfulness," "It Is Well With My Soul," "Jesus Thou Joy of Loving Hearts," "Loved With Everlasting Love," "A Mighty Fortress," and on and on.

I've got probably 40 or 50 hymns here in this little booklet. We learned them by heart and children learn them without any effort whatsoever. You don't have to sit down and memorize, you just sing. And so we learned them and we learned all the stanzas. In my dark times, of which I have had many, I haven't had this little book along with me by any means, but I can sing them in my head if I'm in a place where I don't want to be bothering other people. But I know virtually every line of every hymn.

Nancy Leigh DeMoss: Just outside the studio here, moments ago we were on a break and I heard the instrumental music playing over the sound system "He Hideth My Soul." And even in the midst of this day of recording sessions, the thought of the words that go with that just so ministered grace and assurance and confidence to my heart. And I think that for those who have not grown up experiencing and learning and singing these hymns, there is a real loss.

I have made a habit, over many years, of traveling with a hymnal. I travel a great deal but one of the things I manage to slip into my suitcase is a hymnal. I enjoy singing through a hymnal and often dating when I have sung that hymn (of course, all stanzas). There are so many of those we miss when we do sing hymns in our churches today. But then I can go back and have, in a sense, in those hymnals a record of God's dealing with me and how He has ministered to my life with those truths over many years.

Elisabeth Elliot: When I was speaking at a church someplace where I've forgotten, they were singing praise songs and choruses. I said something to the lady that was sitting next to me on the platform, I said, "Do they sing hymns here?"

And she said, "I don't think so. What is a hymn?"

And so I told her what I thought a hymn was. So she went to somebody else and said, "You know, Elisabeth can play the piano. She can play these hymns. Why don't you ask her to do this?"

So they did ask me and those people were just swept away. They gave me a standing ovation and wanted me to teach them a hymn right then and there before I even had a chance to get up to give the talk on whatever it was I was supposed to give. My heart just went out to them. I thought, surely somebody must know something about hymns. But it appeared that nobody had until then, and they just were swept away. They were just delighted. So it's a great loss in so many places

Nancy Leigh DeMoss: I think people who are not comfortable with hymns and singing to the Lord generally are probably not going to be as comfortable in Heaven, because we know that hymns and praise will be the language--part of the language--of Heaven. You go back to the Old Testament and you have the hymn of Moses. And you come to the book of Revelation and you have the hymn of Moses. How many times through the Scripture we are told to "sing to the Lord." I really believe not just for our public worship as we gather corporately, but that individually there is something very restorative and healing and deepening in our walk with the Lord through singing.

I have women frequently today who talk with me about the area of depression and living with these emotions controlling their lives. And the two things I have said practically to women--two questions I ask are--Are you memorizing Scripture? and Are you singing to the Lord?

I find that in those times of sorrow or confusion or difficulty in my own life, that to quote Scripture back to the Lord and to sing to the Lord--and sometimes it is just sing until the cloud lifts, however long it takes. There is something, I believe very...as we lift our hearts up to the Lord by faith, and singing praise to the Lord sometimes is a sacrifice of thanksgiving, that faith pleases God. And I believe He comes and meets with us; He inhabits the praises of His people. So it's not really an optional thing in the Christian life. We might quibble about what style, but to sing to the Lord is really the heart of what we are talking about.

Thursday, September 03, 2009

Some Initial Considerations of Music and its Relationship to Christian Culture

This is an excellent article written by David Ledgerwood Chair of Department of Fine Arts at Maranatha Baptist Bible College. I encourage you to click the link above, print it, and prayerfully ponder this timely article.


He makes these eight propositions concerning music and cultural expression:


  1. Every culture has aspects of its art that reflect sensuality, rebellion, and false worship.
  2. Music both reflects and affects culture.
  3. Musical meaning can be intrinsic, associative or both.
  4. The meaning of music is strongest within its own culture, but there is a move to a "world culture" or "world music" that communicates throughout the world.
  5. Cultural values can and should be evaluated upon biblical absolutes.
  6. Musical styles within a culture are fluid; musical meaning is often contextual.
  7. Since musical styles are fluid, churches that build their music programs on what is popular are shooting at a moving target.
  8. Music can be very addicting.

His concluding paragraph asks some very poignant questions worthy of reflection by discerning believers today.

  • Does music have a hold on you?
  • Do you turn to it to soothe yourself, to help you escape from reality?
  • Do you listen to music so that you don't have to listen to the voice of your conscience?
  • Do you listen to it to help "put you in the mood" of something that is not right?
  • Are we so far away from God as to believe that we can somehow offer our sensual worship to God and that He is obligated to accept it?

Monday, August 31, 2009

Cantus Firmus

I have always appreciated the terminology employed by Dietrich Bonhoeffer as he described life to his friend. He spoke in musical terms, and in so doing ushered in the idea that life cannot be reduced to one note or a monotone. The cantus firmus, which means "fixed song," is a pre-existing melody that forms the basis of a polyphonic composition. Though the song introduces twists in pitch and style, counterpoint and refrain, the cantus firmus is the enduring melody not always in the forefront, but always playing somewhere within the composition. For Dietrich Bonhoeffer, life was a great work of sounds and symphonic directions, and the cantus firmus was the essence, the soul of the concerto.

With these terms, he wrote: "God wants us to love him eternally with our whole hearts, not in such a way as to injure or weaken earthly life, but to provide a kind of cantus firmus to which the other melodies of life provide the counterpoint... Where the cantus firmus is clear and plain, the counterpoint can be developed to its limits."(1)

As he penned these lines, Bonhoeffer, who was facing execution and the looming end of his life, confessed life to be an awe-inspiring symphony, a melody to behold with attention and appreciation for a great array of intricate choruses. In this intricacy, there is no better song composed than one that finds as its ground bass a wholehearted love of God. Where the enduring melody of life itself is a tune written and played for God, the composition can resound unto the heavens. It is this type of melody that endures even beyond the chorister who sang it.

When Jesus spoke of life, he, too, spoke of multiple realms, of life as it is on earth and in heaven. Like a great composition, there are layers to faith and belief, Communion and the Kingdom, story and song. There is a sense in which all of our stories are the same, written by the great composer of music and sound. And yet, each song is also uniquely our own. For me, as no doubt for you, there have been minor sounds when God seems absent or life seems removed from any chorus of hope. Then again, there have also been moments when the cantus firmus of truth and love resounds in major tones and God comes near in the doxology.

So how do we tell the story of a human life? How do we put into words counterpoints and melodies and tempos? Like the one after God's own heart, perhaps we start with the song at the center of our own souls, as we listen for the arrangement in our neighbors':

"By day the LORD directs his love,
at night his song is with me-
a prayer to the God of my life" (Psalm 42:8).

God's presence is the cantus firmus, set in the deepest center of a life, discovered and embraced over a lifetime. God's love is the enduring melody that puts our stories to song.

Jill Carattini is managing editor of A Slice of Infinity at Ravi Zacharias International Ministries in Atlanta, Georgia.

(1) Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Letters and Papers from Prison (New York: Simon & Schuster, 1997), 303.

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Dan Lucarini -- Why I Left The Contemporary Christian Music Movement


A former Worship leader tells his story why he left the Contemporary Christian Music Movement.


Dedication by Dan Lucarini
This book is dedicated to the authors, pastors, music ministers and others who
came before me. They never ceased to warn us about the dangers of rock music
to a Christian; but we did not take heed. They had the courage to confront others
in the church who defended every controversial and sensual music style; but in
return we heaped scorn upon them. When they dared to oppose the contemporary
music invasion into the church service itself, we called them legalists and worse.
Many have sacrificed popularity and seen their ministry opportunities limited,
because their consciences dictated they must take a stand.

Forward



Music has often been a "hot potato" in the life of the
Christian church, and the subject may never have
been more controversial than duringthe past fifty years.

At one end of the spectrum, there are those who tell us

that the only words that should be sung in the church

are those forming the Old Testament Psalms -- and that

they should be sung without any musical accompaniment.

At the other end, there are those who say that any

kind of music -- rock, pop, jazz, punk, country and

western, rap, or whatever 'turns people on' is

perfectly legitimate for use in worshipand evangelism.

Dan Lucarini never approached the first of these extremes,

but he came within touching distance of the second,

and it is from his deeply involved experience of the modern

music scene, secular and otherwise, that this book is written.

The author's honest sharing of his own spiritual and musical

journey prepares the way for his assessment of what he sees

to be a major problem in today's church -- and makes it more

difficult to deny that he in on to something.

This book will undoubtedly raise many hackles,

but Lucarini's direct and uncompromising style is harnessed

to a gracious spirit concerned with nothing else but God's glory.

This is nowhere more evident than in his warm and wise

treatment of the subject of worship and ministry.

John Calvin once wrote, "We know by experience that music

has a secret and almost incredible power to move hearts."

The reformer was right -- and we should therefore give its

use in the life of the church serious and God-centered

attention.

I pray that this book will help us to do so.

John Blanchard

Thursday, July 30, 2009

Amazing Grace ~ Original Lyrics ~




Faith's Review and Expectation by John Newton
Based on 1 Chronicles 17.16-17
As it appears in Olney Hymns, 1779
Amazing grace! (how sweet the sound)
That sav’d a wretch like me!
I once was lost, but now am found,
Was blind, but now I see.

’Twas grace that taught my heart to fear,
And grace my fears reliev’d;
How precious did that grace appear,
The hour I first believ’d!

Thro’ many dangers, toils and snares,
I have already come;
’Tis grace has brought me safe thus far,
And grace will lead me home.

The Lord has promis’d good to me,
His word my hope secures;
He will my shield and portion be,
As long as life endures.

Yes, when this flesh and heart shall fail,
And mortal life shall cease;
I shall possess, within the veil,
A life of joy and peace.

The earth shall soon dissolve like snow,
The sun forbear to shine;
But God, who call’d me here below,
Will be forever mine.

[The following verse was added in E.O. Excell's Coronation Hymns, 1910]
When we've been there ten thousand years,
Bright shining as the sun,
We've no less days to sing God's praise
Than when we first begun.

Newton's text was first set to the tune NEW BRITAIN in William Walker's Southern Harmony, 1835.
Retrieved from "
http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Amazing_Grace"

Thursday, July 16, 2009

Message Churches are not immune to the subtle infiltration of the wrong kind of music...


Click here
for the original article
published October 2000 in Believers International News.

The Problem With Scoops and Slides

The Problem with Scoops and Slides
[print version] [audio version ]

How do we determine whether or not a particular performance technique is good or bad? What is the ultimate standard whether or not a vocal or instrumental variation is appropriate for Christian music?I believe that we must determine the purpose behind using a particular performance technique, and compare that purpose with our definition of Christian music. Here is a short summary of what I believe Christian music is:

Christian music consists of a clear, distraction-free message that is Biblical in content and delivery, Holy Spirit-filled, that is directed to the Lord, is performed as a means of edifying, teaching and admonishing fellow believers, and is testimony to the lost.

How then does this compare with the purposes of various vocal techniques that are used by contemporary musicians, such as scoops, slides, excessive syncopation, trills, ornamentation, straight tones, riffs, portamento, etc.?

I see several reasons why a singer would utilize these techniques.
  1. To draw attention to the vocal prowess of the performer
  2. To manipulate the emotions of the listener
  3. To imitate another singer
  4. To communicate sensuality
  5. To create a particular atmosphere
  6. To fit into a particular style or genre of music
  7. To relate to a certain group of people

I believe that these techniques tend to violate at least three clear Biblical principles:

  • Do not fulfill the lust of the flesh (Gal. 5:16)
  • Do not exhibit pride (Pro. 8:13)
  • Abstain from all appearance of evil (1 Thess. 5:22)

Christian music should never be mistaken for negative styles of music, such as the music of immorality or rebellion.

Properly used performance techniques are like spices. When used discreetly, they may be helpful in certain rare applications. All aspects of musical performance should be analyzed to see if they meet the following criteria: they should

  • Enhance
  • Beautify
  • Illustrate
  • Support
  • Clarify
  • Intensify
  • Strengthen
  • Reinforce

the message of the text.

In other words, if a particular performance technique is a help in communicating a godly message, it is perfectly acceptable to use it. If it is a distraction from the message of the song, for whatever reason, that performance technique should be avoided.

The problem with most vocal ornamentations is that they are almost exclusively used for the wrong reasons. Scooping and sliding and riffing are mostly manipulative, sensual, and self-promotional in nature and should not be used.

Music that clearly communicates a strong, positive, Biblical message will emphasize the text by using proper emphasis, word color, effective phrasing, and appropriate dynamic and tempo changes. Our music needs to be passionate, heartfelt and excellent, not manipulative, showy, or sleazy, in order to reach the intended audience.

Keep Me In Your Will

Keep Me In Your Will

Sometimes I think I'm in control
And I act so foolishly
Facing problems on my own
I don't know what's best for me
My mistakes at times disturb
All the plans you have made
Lord, keep me in your will
So, I won't be in your way

And, put me where you want to
Not where I want to be
If I should ask, for things I want
Just give me what I need
When I complain from time to time
Forgive me Lord I pray
Lord keep me in your will
So I won't be in your way

Remind me Lord, I'm just a glove
In which you place your hand
Not my will, but your's be done
Though I don't understand
The best laid plans I've made
Somehow always go astray
Lord keep me in your will
So I won't be in your way

And put me where you want to
Not where I want to be
If I should ask for things I wantJust give me what I need
When I complain from time to time
Forgive me Lord I pray
Lord keep me in your will
So I won't be in your way

I need you dear Lord
I need you each and every day
Lord keep me in your will
So I won't be in your way
Just keep me in your will
So I won't be in your way